Notes of a meeting between HMRC Managers, Debbie Urquhart-Cannon and Neil Richardson, dated 13 December, 2007, after Neil Richardson (on behalf of HMRC) charged HMRC Whistleblower, Andi Ali with a fundamental breach of contract for raising concerns of corruption within the department under the Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998. (At an employment tribunal hearing in 2008, HMRC Solicitor Ian Painter, admitted to the court that many of the comments Urquhart – Cannon made against Mr Ali were false, and Urquhart – Cannon only made them because HMRC had offered her a bung (a promotion) to lie about Mr Ali because he had blown the whistle on corruption within the department.